I think it works well.
Pretty darn bueno. I like the red gradients.
I kind of miss the old logo you had, but the new look is a lot cleaner.
Very nice. Kinda fits for a dating sim. Just needs some ponies, perhaps in the header? (If that can be done, anyway.)
Smooth and simple. It's nice.
We have recently got a web designer on our team, and have assigned him with the task of creating a new site theme. It will be classy, sleek and include ponies.
The official blog.